Wednesday 22 February 2012

Presumption of Death

‘A ‘crazy paving’ of statutory and common law provisions’[1] is how the current law relating to resolving the affairs of missing people has been described. MP’s are calling for the Ministry of Justice to introduce new legislation which will make it easier for families to resolve the affairs of missing people. The proposed legislation is based on the Scottish Presumption of Death Act 1977 under which an average of four orders are made each year.
If successful, a presumption of death order would be obtainable after seven years of a person’s disappearance; this would put an end to all legal issues surrounding the person, much as a death certificate would. However, it has also been suggested that extra provisions are brought in to deal with the missing person’s financial affairs up to four years before the presumption of death order can be awarded. These will be known as ‘guardianship’ orders and would allow families to deal with the person’s property, including the paying off of mortgages, dealing with direct debits, cancelling credit cards or even providing maintenance for any dependants of the missing person.
People such as Rachel Elias and Peter Lawrence, both, who have suffered the tragedy of a disappearing family member, support the proposals. Peter Lawrence has described the difficulties that he faced following the disappearance of his daughter. He says that it was impossible to cancel her direct debits, or switch money between bank accounts due to the lack of suitable legislation.  If the proposals are to come into force, then families of those that a presumed to be dead will have a greater peace of mind when it comes to dealing with their affairs.
Critics of the proposed legislation claim that it is dangerous to presume a death has occurred with no evidence and therefore, their affairs should not be meddled with. However in the 34 years since Scotland introduced its Presumption of Death Act only one person has ever reappeared.
 



No comments:

Post a Comment